Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Which side of the clock are you on?

There are arguments - some valid, some not, on both sides of this discussion. Trump has revived efforts to enact permanent daylight saving time, seeking to eliminate the twice-yearly clock adjustments that have long frustrated many of us - me especially.. Proponents argue the change would extend evening daylight, boost retail and outdoor activity, and simplify scheduling across states. The proposal carries weight because Trump remains the dominant figure in Republican politics and could influence congressional priorities if his party holds power.
The debate over permanent DST has resurfaced periodically, with past bills stalling over concerns about darker winter mornings, impacts on schoolchildren and farmers, and regional differences in sunrise times. Republicans have historically split on the issue, with some viewing it as a quality-of-life improvement and others warning of unintended consequences for energy use and public safety. The timing of Trump's latest push coincides with ongoing discussions about broader regulatory and time-related policies.
The cartoon argues that Trump's aggressive push for permanent daylight saving time risks harming the Republican Party itself. There is no sound reason for clocks to change now that kids are no longer tending the farm before going to school. 
The argument against has kids waiting for school busses in the dark. I grew up at a time when kids either walked, rode their bikes or took public transportation to school. Those things rarely exist anymore in todays' society. 
Where do you guys stand on this? For me, I don't like the sun setting at 4:30 
in January. Makes Happy Hour gloomy. Juss' sayin'...




13 comments:

  1. Never rode a school bus in my life - activity bus, yes. Walked to elementary school, bike/carpooled to Jr. High, drove to HS, as you could get your license in Mississippi at 15 yrs., 1 mo. if you'd taken a year of Driver's Ed and did two road tests with your instructor.

    ReplyDelete
  2. What ever works for Arizona should work for the rest of us.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Why not compromise and change the clocks 1/2 hour forward and leave it there?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'd say this is a perfect example of Thomas Sowell's principle that there are no ideal solutions, only tradeoffs. As you say, both sides have valid arguments. (And as a matter of fact there's a middle school at the end of my suburban street and kids walk to it every day.) Personally, though, I have a hard time understanding why some people get so passionately outraged about changing clocks twice a year. It takes what, maybe ten minutes every six months? Yet these same people meekly spend hours or days doing their taxes every April and don't bitch about that. Go figure.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Back in the 70s during OPEC's stranglehold on the US, one of the idiots in charge (Dick, Jerry or Jimmah, I forget which) mandated permanent DST for the winter. We waited in the dark & cold for the school bus. So what? We survived just fine. Kids up here do the same from November to March regardless of whether it's standard or daylight time. They come home in the dark too. Again, so what? They handle it. To all those opposed to choosing one or the other and wanting to keep this clock changing stupidity alive I say: Grow the fuck up & deal with it, ya TDS afflicted great wet lettuce.

    ReplyDelete
  6. doesn't matter to me just quit changing it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Drop DST permanently. No point in jumping back and forth twice a year now that we have electric lighting available. It might have made sense when factories were barely lit but now it does not. Noon should still be when the sun is (close to) the zenith.

    ReplyDelete
  8. We also don't need daylight savings time for longer daylight periods in the summer as those kids still are not working the farm after school either. This only started in 1966. How did we ever survive without it for the first 190 years of our country's existence? Predident Wilson tried it during WWI and it was repealed because it was so disliked. FDR did it again during WWII and it was repealed after the war. Then in 1966, the Democrat-controlled Congress (see a pattern developing here?) made it offifcal again. It is to my deep regret that the Republicans extended it out on each side. Just go back to standard time. It worked just fine for for most of the coutry's existence. Full disclosure: I'm retiring to the Philippines next year. They're too close to the equator for DST to make much of a difference for them their days are 12 hours long Plus/Minus 45 minutes between summer and winter. no matter how you slice it is dark by 6:30 pm there in the summer. Now days the best reason I hear for keeping DST is "I can play golf later into the evening." I could care less about pleasing a handful of people who play golf.

    ReplyDelete
  9. No, natural phenomenon... daylight, is not a"extended" or otherwise effected by the laws of man.

    Numbers are arbitrary. Extremely long tradition has pegged "high noon" to 12 O'Clock. If modern globalism makes that longetudinal ambiguity inconvenient, then put *everyone* on GMT. It doesn't matter what the numbers are, what matters is that they are *standard*, that they don't keep changing.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Pick one. I don't care, though I prefer Standard Time. Before I retired, I drove to work in the dark in the winter anyway. Around here, the buses pick up the kids in the dark. Back in the day when I had Migraine headaches, the time change in either direction cost me a week of headaches. My dog is older and calmer now, but she went crazy for a while with the Fall change. The arguments for permanent DST don't persuade me, the kids in the dark and someone always mentions Golf, about which I have no F's to give, as my brother would say.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Set it back 1/2hour. Then everyone is happy. Solved can I get on with life now?

    ReplyDelete
  12. While I can occasionally miss the mark by hours, most times I surprise myself by being so accurate in picking the time of my nocturnal wake-ups and I think changing the clock twice a year takes some unnecessary adjustment. Hell, you’ve got me thinking of a term all the rage a few decades ago… BIORHYTHMS

    ReplyDelete
  13. Ex-WI. I went to school while it was dark and snowing. I came home and it was dark and snowing. Then I did the same while working.

    ReplyDelete

Pucker up, boys...

This picture shows 18-year-old actress Marilyn Hare kissing a U.S. soldier during a 1942 visit to a California military training camp, photo...